DevelopmentOctober 20266 min read

Feasibility Before Vision: Why Development Appraisals Fail in East Africa

A feasibility study that confirms the developer's intention has no value. This paper examines the four appraisal errors that most reliably produce a project the market cannot support — and the sequence that avoids them.

Graham Stewart Leslie · Principal & Founder

01

The appraisal is written after the decision

In too many projects the product is fixed by the time the feasibility is commissioned: key count, room mix, restaurant count and residential component are already drawn. The study then works backwards to justify the drawings. The result is a document that satisfies a lender's checklist while removing the one thing feasibility exists to provide — an independent view.

02

Capital cost is treated as an estimate, not a constraint

On-island construction, imported finishes, logistics and the cost of building to an international brand standard are frequently underestimated at concept stage. When the true cost emerges, the response is usually to add keys or residential units to dilute the per-key cost — which changes the product, the market and often the returns.

03

The operating model is left until later

Brand selection, management terms and pre-opening costs materially affect the investment case, yet they are often deferred until after the capital structure is set. By then the owner has less room to negotiate and less evidence with which to do it.

Implications

  • Commission the appraisal before the design is frozen.
  • Test the capital cost at a realistic, on-island build standard.
  • Settle brand and operating structure before the funding structure closes.

If this bears on a decision you are making, the view can be tested against your specific asset.

Discuss this paper